How to Design a Luxury Rental Property That Protects Its Value

Most luxury rentals underperform — not because of location or price point, but because they were designed wrong. The right surfaces age gracefully. The wrong ones look tired by year two. That means bad reviews, lost bookings, tenant complaints, and a property that's harder to sell when the time comes.

A well-designed rental does two things at once: it commands a strong rate, and it holds its quality across years of use. Those two goals can reinforce each other — or work against each other — depending on the decisions made at the start.

Surfaces that survive turnover

The most important call in a rental is what goes on the floors, walls, and counters.

Floors. Engineered hardwood or large-format porcelain that reads like natural stone. Avoid solid hardwood — it requires refinishing on a turnover cycle.

Walls. High-quality matte paint. The right matte formulation wipes clean and looks far more luxurious than shinier finishes. Wallpaper is a strong option in a luxury rental as long as it's a durable, scrubbable wallcovering — luxury vinyl or similar. It adds real personality and actually protects the wall better than paint.

Counters. Quartzite — natural stone — is the right call for luxury rentals. It's far more beautiful than engineered surfaces and holds up well when properly sealed. Quartz (the engineered version) is a viable fallback if regular maintenance can't be guaranteed, but it lacks the presence of natural stone. Avoid marble in rental contexts: white marble in particular can yellow from moisture exposure and develop watermarks if it's not resealed on a regular schedule.

Cabinetry. Painted cabinetry shows wear; thermofoil shows worse. The right call for a luxury rental is factory-finished natural wood — stained, not painted — or a high-quality matte laminate like Fenix, which is extremely durable, resists fingerprints and scratches, and reads as sophisticated rather than utilitarian.

Hardware and fixtures. Solid brass or stainless rather than plated finishes. Plated finishes look identical on day one and start showing wear within a year on a high-turnover property.

Furniture that holds up

The two most common rental furniture failures are upholstery wear and structural collapse. Both are avoidable before purchasing.

Sofas and chairs: performance fabrics — Perennials and their high-end equivalents — are now indistinguishable from natural-fiber upholstery to the eye, but they resist stains, spills, and wear over time. For case goods: solid wood frames with dovetail drawers and mortise-and-tenon construction, not veneer over MDF. The premium pays back across three to five turnovers.

Beds: Hospitality-grade mattresses paired with a solid-platform frame — one where the mattress sits on a firm, flat base rather than slats, the standard in high-end hotels. It prevents the mattress from shifting and is easier to clean around. Upholstered headboards are a strong choice in a luxury rental: they photograph beautifully and add warmth. Specify performance fabric and they hold up just as well as everything else.

Photography and listing performance

In luxury short-term rental markets, listing photography drives more of the nightly rate than any other single variable. Design choices that read flat in photos actively cost money.

What photographs well:

• Layered lighting — table lamps, sconces, and ceiling — rather than overhead only

• Color depth in textiles rather than all-white styling, which washes out on camera

• Art at scale: pieces that hold the wall, not small prints that disappear

• Material variation — stone, wood, fabric, and metal visible in the same frame

A property re-photographed after a redesign routinely outperforms the same listing at the same address and price point. The photo is the product.

Where to spend, where to save

Spend on: counters, cabinetry, lighting, floors, beds, and primary furniture. These drive both listing quality and longevity.

Commodity-grade is fine for: accessories, throws, kitchenware, art prints. These cycle out and shouldn't carry sunk-cost expectations.

Skip: custom millwork tied to a specific use case, heavy personalization, anything that requires owner-level maintenance.

The operations dimension

A beautiful design that creates daily problems for the property manager will lose money even at strong rates. The best rental designs are built with operations in mind: cleanable surfaces, replaceable components, layouts that allow full turnover in a standard cleaning window.

If you're planning to bring on a property manager, involving them before final design decisions are made is worth doing. They know which surfaces have failed in the properties they manage, and that knowledge is worth more than any spec sheet.

Investment property design is a specialty

A well-designed rental isn't a lower tier of design — it's a different one. The decisions that protect long-term value differ meaningfully from what works in a primary residence, and the results show up in rate, reviews, and eventually resale.

If you're acquiring or repositioning a rental property in New York, the Hamptons, Long Island, or Miami, book a consultation. We'll look at the property against both the rate model and the long-term value model, and scope the design to serve both.

Paul De Andrade is the founder and principal designer of Studio Kestrel, a residential interior design practice working across New York City, the Hamptons, and Miami. He has been designing interiors since 2014, founded Studio Kestrel in 2019, and has completed more than 30 full-service projects through the studio since. His work is rooted in organic modern principles, feng shui, and a wellness-led approach to how a home is built around daily life. Studio Kestrel has been featured in Architectural Digest, The Wall Street Journal, Homes & Gardens, Domino, and Hamptons Magazine, among others.

More about Paul → | Book a consultation →